Metal Roof vs. Asphalt Shingle Roof: Which One is Right for You?

Metal roofs and asphalt shingle roofs are considered to be the two most common types of roofing options across the US. If you are looking to upgrade your existing roof and are trying to choose between metal roofing and asphalt shingles, this article can help you. Read more to find out about the prominent features of both against each other.

Metal Roof vs. Asphalt Shingle Roof
Metal Roof vs. Asphalt Shingle Roof

Metal Roof vs. Asphalt Shingle Roof: Which Is the Best Choice for Your Home?

Making your mind to install a certain type of roof in your house is never an easy decision to make. There are many factors that you have to consider, starting from the budget limitations that you have to how much it will last.

To make this decision easier for you, here is a detailed note about the prominent features of the two most common types of roofing options to choose from.

Asphalt Shingle Roofs

Asphalt shingle roofs are considered to be the most widely installed roofing type across the UK today. Because of many factors involved, of course, the cheap installation charges and ease of installation stand out the most.

Here are some of the pros and cons of installing asphalt shingle roofs:

Ease Of Installation

Probably the most important pro-factor of having an asphalt shingle roof installed in your home is its effortlessly easy installation and allowance for repairs. You can potentially save a fortune in investment by looking up DIY methods to do so and getting under the task yourself.

The technical knowledge and skill required for the installation of asphalt shingle roofs is quite minimal and can be done by hiring any local roofing specialists.


Asphalt shingle roofs are known to last quite a while, however, not as long as metal roofs. 

The average lifespan of an asphalt shingle roof can be said to be somewhere between 15-25 years; it can very likely exceed this with proper care and maintenance.

For the investment that you make in installing asphalt shingle roofs in your house, they surely do last time against that.


Using materials that are environmentally friendly is a necessity in the times that we live in today. Asphalt shingles are known to be among some of the most eco-friendly roofing options available in the market today.

Most materials used in asphalt shingle roofing are products that are recycled; this counts pretty well in sustaining the flow of discarded material.


The expenses are a major factor to consider when installing any type of roof in your house. You surely do want something that is going to last you a lifetime with the least repairs and maintenance required but never can be ready to make the highest investment.

Asphalt shingle roofs are considered to be among some of the cheapest roofing options in the market, counting as low as 1/3 of the prices of the competitive options.

Since the installation process is quite easy and requires the least technical knowledge, the labor charges incurred upon you are going to be quite very nominal as well.

Metal Roofs

Metal roofs are among the top-favorite choices and preferences of many homeowners and roofing contractors across the USA, mostly because of the long-lasting lifespan and strong durability that they offer. 

Here are some pros and cons of installing a metal roof in your house:

Ease Of Installation

When it comes to the installation of metal roofs in your house, you surely can’t rely on DIY tutorials off the internet or a layman technician.

Metal roof installation is a tricky process that requires precise skill and delicacy; hiring a professional roofer is a necessity.

Since the involvement of a large number of slabs and screws to hold the roof together, it might be more than a pain to figure out repairs on a metal roof when it comes to leaks and roof damage.

Metal Standing Seam 

Metal roofing with standing seams is the best roof type for the installation of solar panels. The standing seams on these roofs make the attachment of the panel array incredibly easy, and with easier installation comes a cheaper cost.


Metal roofs are known to probably be the strongest and most long-lasting roofing options available in the market today.

With some types of metal roofing that exceed the life expectancy of over 70-80 years, the average life remains anywhere between 40-60 years.

So if you are looking for something that is going to last you a definite lifetime, a metal roof is surely the best option for you!


Going eco-friendly counts a lot when choosing a permanent addition to your home. Even though the other roofing options available might have a certain green factor involved, it surely can’t be matched by that of a metal roof.

Metal roofs are completely recyclable, even though when a metal roof has well exceeded its time of use, it can be scrapped and reprocessed to produce a similar roof with the same durability.  


Counting on the expenses involved in the installation and maintenance of your roof, the metal roof is surely not going to stand out amongst the cheapest options available.

The technical and tricky installment and metal roof repair requirements will compel you to hire a skilled professional for it, which will also have higher labor charges.

But taking into account the worth of your money, a metal roof is going to stand firm 2 or even 3 times over when other roofing options deteriorate. So it surely isn’t the cheapest upfront investment, but definitely a worthy one in the long run.


The preference of choosing a certain roofing type to install at your home is a highly personal decision; you may find it best to install a metal roof if you’re living in an area that receives a lot of precipitation and may find it best to install an asphalt shingle roof if you are running low on budget.

Both the roofing options offer benefits of their own that cannot be matched or rivaled by their competitors. At the end of the day, it is you who has to decide which pros fall in your favor and which cons are against you in your situation.

The Scientific World

The Scientific World is a Scientific and Technical Information Network that provides readers with informative & educational blogs and articles. Site Admin: Mahtab Alam Quddusi - Blogger, writer and digital publisher.

Previous Post Next Post